Critical Lessons from George Clooney’s Good Night, and Good Luck
As Clooney’s recent play reveals, the struggle between truth and political intimidation is not confined to history but continues to challenge democratic societies today. Moreover, when journalism falters, democracy becomes vulnerable.
George Clooney recently returned to the stage in a powerful Broadway adaptation of Good Night, and Good Luck, co-written with longtime collaborator Grant Heslov. The play, which opened on April 3, 2025, and concluded its theatrical run on June 8, 2025, revisited the legacy of legendary CBS journalist Edward R. Murrow and his fearless confrontation with Senator Joseph McCarthy during the height of the McCarthy era in the 1950s (known as the Red Scare). Clooney, in a performance lauded for its gravity and discipline, portrayed Murrow with quiet authority, leading audiences through a pivotal moment in American history when fear-mongering and state intimidation threatened to silence dissent and undermine democratic norms.
The production’s reach extended far beyond the theater. Its final performance on June 8 was broadcast live on CNN, drawing over 7.34 million viewers worldwide — 5.64 million in the United States alone — with additional audiences tuning in via CNN’s digital platforms and Max. According to Broadway News, it became the most-watched cable program, underscoring both the show’s cultural resonance and the public’s appetite for stories that grapple with truth, accountability, and civic responsibility.
Though set in the 1950s, the play’s warning is strikingly applicable to today’s political climate. The current administration has increasingly relied on disinformation, fear, and retaliatory tactics to consolidate power — from smearing political opponents and journalists to undermining the legitimacy of the press, the judiciary, universities, and scientific and medical research. Echoes of McCarthyism resound as political figures invoke national security and patriotism to justify authoritarian behavior, stoke division, and sidestep constitutional constraints. In this context, Good Night, and Good Luck is not just a period piece — it’s a timely indictment of a political strategy that corrodes democratic safeguards and weaponizes public trust for personal and partisan gain.
Below are the key takeaways from the production and how they speak directly to the responsibilities of modern citizens and journalists alike.
The Importance of a Free and Courageous Press
On stage, Murrow’s principled reporting serves as a bulwark against McCarthy’s reckless abuse of power. Murrow and his CBS team push forward with their broadcasts not because it is safe, but because it is necessary. The production reminds us that journalism’s highest calling is to speak truth to power — even when doing so is unpopular or dangerous.
In an era of disinformation and deep political division, a free and independent press is more essential than ever. Journalists must remain fearless in pursuing facts and refusing to be manipulated by those in authority. Their work is not entertainment; it is a democratic safeguard.
Fear Is a Tool of Manipulation
The play vividly portrays how McCarthy stokes public anxiety about communism to centralize power and silence dissent. Fear is not just an emotion — it becomes a tool of political strategy, and one that quickly corrodes public trust and civil liberties.
From populist rhetoric to conspiracy-driven media, fear is often used to justify draconian policies and marginalize vulnerable communities. Citizens must recognize and resist this tactic, demanding leadership that appeals to reason and evidence, not panic.
Power Tends to Corrupt: The Need to Expose It
One of the play’s most sobering messages echoes the famous warning by Lord Acton: “Power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely.” McCarthy’s unchecked authority — and the culture of fear that allowed it — offers a chilling case study in what happens when power goes unchallenged.
The production makes it clear: corruption does not begin with overt criminality. It begins with the small compromises, the silencing of dissent, and the erosion of accountability. Murrow’s broadcasts challenged this, not only exposing McCarthy’s lies but reminding the public that no one is above scrutiny.
In any democracy, power must be constantly examined. A vigilant press is not a luxury — it is a necessity. When journalists shrink from holding powerful figures accountable, corruption flourishes in the shadows. Media institutions and reporters must remain alert, persistent, and unafraid to question those who operate in positions of influence — whether in government, business, or their own industry.
The Powerful Prey on the Weak
One of the most emotionally devastating moments in Good Night, and Good Luck is the death of Don Hollenbeck, a fellow CBS newsman portrayed as a thoughtful but deeply troubled journalist under siege. Accused of communist sympathies and hounded by public attacks, Hollenbeck ultimately takes his own life. His suicide near the end of the play underscores the personal cost of political persecution.
Hollenbeck’s fate serves as a symbol of how those corrupted by power often target the vulnerable — those without the means to defend themselves or the public standing to resist character assassination. The play makes a harrowing point: the architects of fear do not concern themselves with the collateral damage of their ambition — whether it be a person’s reputation, livelihood, or life.
From whistleblowers and activists to marginalized communities and targeted journalists, the vulnerable remain the first casualties of unchecked power. The lesson is that indifference is complicity. Societies must protect those at risk, amplify their voices, and ensure that power is not allowed to destroy lives in silence.
The Necessity of Institutional Integrity
Throughout the play, CBS executives are shown grappling with political and commercial pressures. The decision to air Murrow’s segments was not made lightly — it required courage and conviction from within the institution.
Media organizations today face similar conflicts between profitability and principle. The lesson here is that individuals inside these institutions — producers, editors, anchors — must act with integrity. Upholding truth is not just the job of the individual reporter; it is the responsibility of the system that supports them.
Silence and Complicity Are Dangerous
One of the more haunting elements of the play is the silence of the many who chose to say nothing during the McCarthy era. Their passivity allowed lies to harden into policy and fear to dictate public life.
Whether in media, politics, or daily life, silence in the face of injustice empowers those who spread it. The audience is reminded that the greatest threats to democracy often thrive not in noise, but in quiet compliance.
Media Must Challenge Power, Not Entertain It
Murrow’s monologue in the play warns against television becoming a vehicle for distraction rather than a tool for enlightenment. When journalism is diluted into entertainment, it loses its ability to inform and inspire action.
The danger of infotainment is more acute than ever. With viral content, influencer-driven news, and algorithmic echo chambers dominating information streams, the challenge is to preserve space for meaningful, fact-based journalism. Audiences must actively support media that values truth over spectacle.
Conclusion: The Critical Takeaway
As citizens and consumers of news, the most urgent takeaway from Good Night, and Good Luck — powerfully reimagined for the stage — is this: Democracy demands a vigilant, ethical press and a public that insists on accountability. Lord Acton’s warning reminds us that power unchecked will almost certainly lead to corruption. Murrow’s legacy, brought to life in Clooney’s performance, is a stirring call to vigilance — not only for journalists, but for all of us. In an era of growing disinformation, political polarization, and institutional fragility, truth remains our most powerful defense.
Don Hollenbeck’s tragic arc reminds us of the human cost when power goes unchecked and the press fails to shield the vulnerable. The stakes are not abstract — they are reputations, careers, and lives.
As the play closes, Murrow leaves the audience with a pointed reminder, quoting from Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar: “The fault, dear Brutus, is not in our stars, but in ourselves” (Act I, Scene II). The message is clear: we cannot blame fate or circumstance for the erosion of truth and justice. The responsibility lies with us — whether we speak out or stay silent, whether we defend the weak or ignore their suffering, whether we demand integrity or accept corruption. But that responsibility extends beyond action alone; it includes the obligation to discern truth from noise. In an age where algorithms feed outrage and podcast pundits blur facts with opinion, citizens must resist intellectual passivity. Democracy cannot survive on secondhand outrage or selective ignorance. It depends on a public willing to do the work: to question, to verify, and to engage with the world not through the lens of tribalism, but through a clear-eyed pursuit of objective truth.
In the end, the play leaves us with this imperative: speak up, question power, seek out the truth, and support the press that dares to do the same. Good night, and good luck — because the future of democracy depends on it.
________________________________________________________________
If you enjoyed this essay, you might enjoy my book, Serendipitous Discoveries from the Bookshelf, based on my popular blog, Atkins Bookshelf. The blog explores the world of ideas — through books, movies, music, quotations, and the English language — for the intellectually curious. At the heart of Atkins Bookshelf is a lifelong love of books and literature; its goal is to educate, entertain, and inspire.
The book can be found here.
The blog can be found here.
This post is a labor of love. If you enjoyed reading the essay, please consider supporting the research and writing for future posts via Buy Me A Coffee. Thank you so much for your support.
To learn more about Alexander Atkins Design, visit https://alexatkinsdesign.com/
